35 Best Secret Santa Gifts

Secret Santa Gift Guide

Last Updated on November 22, 2022

Secret Santa games and Christmas gift exchange parties are so fun, but sometimes it’s hard to know what to bring!

Do you go ridiculous, sentimental, whimsical, practical? And what about the budget? You don’t want to bring a $50 gift to a $10 party! (Or vice versa…)

Well, we’ve got you covered. Scroll on for some great Secret Santa gifts that anyone will happy to receive!

Our website is supported by our users. We sometimes earn a commission when you click through the affiliate links on our website. Learn more here.

Top 5 Secret Santa Gift Ideas

Let’s start with the best.

1. Custom Birdfeeder

Custom Birdfeeder
Check Latest Price

You can have this beauty engraved with whatever you like, but make sure it says Merry Christmas somewhere! This pretty birdfeeder is custom made so there are no two alike anywhere.

It will make a great gift for any age or gender and really spruces up the backyard. It has a nice size to it, so you don’t have to be constantly refilling the container with seed, and it will bring all those birds flocking.

What a way to brighten up a dreary winter’s day!

2. Herb Garden Kit

At Home Herb Garden Kit
Check Latest Price

Herb gardens are great gifts: they’re inexpensive, easily switched out for other herbs, smell amazing, and don’t take up the room that say, a whole garden does!

They cheer up a kitchen windowsill, and the fruits of your labor can be used for cooking, essential oil mixes, potpourri, healing elixirs, homemade lotions and potions, and… well, the list goes on!

Related: Ultimate Gift Guide for Chefs & Bakers

3. Custom Mix Tape

custom mix tape
Check Latest Price

Everyone loves music. And everyone loves a special playlist made just for them. Share your favorites with your Christmas buddy using this gorgeous custom mix tape!

You can personalize it with a phrase, a QR code, or anything else to make it all the more meaningful.

4. Ultimate Movie Fan Popcorn Set

Check Latest Price

Who wouldn’t love to be on the receiving end of this amazing gift set?!

Movie lovers rejoice with this totally amazing giftbox which includes the yummiest of popcorn (a necessity for movie lovers), cozy socks, different seasonings and toppings, all tucked inside the cutest tin.

Related: 21 Best Movie Lover Gifts

5. Personalized Oak Barrels

Personalized Oak Barrel
Check Latest Price

A more sophisticated Secret Santa gift, this gorgeous bistro-themed oak barrel can be personalized the way you like, which makes it a great gift for an office party (think your company’s logo).

It really makes a statement, and that statement is all the other party goers wish that YOU were their Secret Santa. They’ll remember your amazing gift as they age fine wines at home or put the barrel on display in their home bar.

Need help planning the holidays? We’ve got you covered.

Best Secret Santa Gifts for Her

6. Custom Wine Tumblers

Personalized Wine Tumblers for Her
Check Latest Price

Not only do these wine tumblers look great, with their fancy personalization, but they’re practical and useful too! No more fruit flies going swimming in her Merlot, or rain drops diluting her Chardonnay, when you’ve got a lid. Hurray!

She’s going to totally be obsessed with this during backyard BBQs, campouts, tailgate parties, or just sitting on the porch on a lazy Sunday.

Who even needs stemware?!

7. Pizza Blanket

Large Pizza Blanket
Check Latest Price

This. This right here. You don’t need to scroll any further, you have found THE GIFT TO END ALL GIFTS. If your Secret Santa recipient didn’t swoon over your presents (or presence) up until now, never fear. With this pizza blanket, you will be sitting pretty all year long!

8. Not Just Any Candle… Fernweh Candles

Fernweh Candles
Check Latest Price

A great candle is always a fabulous gift, and this is a great candle! She will love this yummy scent – or choose another that sounds more like “her.” You can’t go wrong with a delicious, delightful, decadent, divine candle.

Ok, we’ll stop with the alliteration now.

9. Revitalash Makeup

Revitalash Make Up
Check Latest Price

The secret is out: Revitalash Makeup is where it’s at! Where what’s at, you may ask, you MANCUB YOU? Why, where plump, lush lashes, glowing skin, and long, luxurious hair is at, of course. A tube of this jaw-dropping lash serum is sold every thirty seconds.

Um, yeah.

Get on board with that. She’ll love this gift.

10. Wood Tone Music Jewelry Box

Wood Tone Music Jewelry Box
Check Latest Price

A pretty spot to store all her favorite jewels and gems is a must for any lady! This shiny wooden box is perfect for that.

As if it weren’t lovely enough as it is, you can make this Secret Santa gift even better by having it personalized with her name, and choosing the tune that it plays when opened.

Don’t forget to add a thoughtful, and personalized card when giving out your Secret Santa gifts this year! Check out our list of 100!

Best Secret Santa Gifts for Him

11. House of Cards Poker Room

Personalized House of Cards Poker Room Sign
Check Latest Price

If he loves hosting poker night with the boys (and girls) this is the gift for him! He’s going to totally fall in love with this personalized sign, love at first sight really.

Whether he hangs it in his man cave, the garage, the den, or even his office, he’s going to smile every time he sees it. And all his poker buddies will definitely wish they had one of their own.

Related: Christmas Gift Ideas for the Home

12. Cracker & Soup Mug Set

Cracker Soup Mug Set
Check Latest Price

When you need some soup, you needs some crackers, are we right? Of course we are! This adorable and totally functional little dish is the answer to the problem he may not have known he had: where to put the crackers?!?

Now we just need to know, can you fit a grilled cheese in there as well? Asking for a friend.

13. Fireball Shooter

Fireball Shooter
Check Latest Price

Don’t question it. Just buy it.

This mini fire shooter is his dream. Sure, fine, whatever… we don’t know him. But he’s dreamed about this. We know it.

14. Gone Fishing Wooden Bottle Opener

Wooden Bottle Opener "Gone Fishing"
Check Latest Price

Whether he really has “gone fishing,” or just wishes he was (as he stares sadly and morosely out of the office window to a concrete jungle), this engraved wood bottle opener is just the thing to boost his spirits!

No more searching the kitchen for that elusive (and teleporting) bottle opener when you have this amazing one right where you left it.

Related: 50 Personalized Gifts just for Him

15. Snacks From Around the World Subscription

Snacks from Around the World
Check Latest Price

The only thing better than a snack is a snack that keeps on arriving to your mailbox every month! Can we get an AMEN? This set of delicious and unique snacks are going to open up a whole new world of culinary delights for him.

Seriously, the “thank you’s” you’re going to get after enrolling him in this scrumptious subscription could fill a whole ‘nother box…

Secret Santa Gifts Under $20

16. Custom Engraved Glass Set

Custom Engraved Glass Set
Check Latest Price

Getting something personalized shows you really put some thought into your Secret Santa gift (not like Sheryl from HR who just gives out Applebee’s gift cards… classic Sheryl).

This cute engraved mug really fits the bill when you need something simple, but still unique and thoughtful. You can put their name, or be cheeky, like “World’s Best Coworker,” or “Future Boss.”

17. Puffin Drinkware Coozie

puffin drinkware coozie
Check Latest Price

These fun coozies come in more styles, colors and varieties than you can shake a stick at! If he’s never had a coozie before he’ll never want to go without after using one of these fun drinking buddies. Whether he’s a vest guy, a puffer guy, team jersey man… you name it, they’ve got it.

18. Mini Inflatable Tube Guy

Mini Inflatable Tub Guy
Check Latest Price

There’s just something oddly soothing about those inflatable sales guys that wave their arms frantically. It reminds us to slow down and pick out a Land Rover already… or something.

Well, anyway, a fun little tabletop one is a cute gift. We dig this little guy with his cherubic face and his freestyle dance moves. And he won’t try to sell you a mattress, so that’s cool too.

19. Self-Heating Ceramic Mug

self-heating ceramic mug
Check Latest Price

Keeping his favorite cuppa joe nice ‘n toasty has never been easier. This super innovative, self-heating mug relies on induction technology to keep coffee at the perfect temperature. You can even use the coaster base to charge your phone!

Available in ten beautiful colors, he’s sure to love this gift.

20. Cashmere Clothing

cashmere clothing
Check Latest Price

It’s a cashmere wonderland over at Gentle Herd! And who would say no to cashmere? He’ll love you forever when you pick out a cozy, soft sweater or a chic jogger suit for him.

Related: 50 Warm & Cozy Gifts for the Holidays

Secret Santa Gifts Under $5

21. Weird Gift: Food Soda

Popular Food Flavored Soda
Check Latest Price

You know, sometimes you just have to think outside the box! These totally tubular “food” sodas are perfect for someone who is hard to shop for, already has everything, or has a cast-iron stomach. Talk about an ice-breaker at a party: pass some of these around!

Available in a six pack with ALL the flavors, these are going to be the gift that the whole party remembers (not like lame-o socks).

Or maybe they’ll just prefer a unique tea gift instead…

22. DIY Secret Santa Gift: Home Baked Cookies

Baked Cookies for Gifts

If you’re out of time (and, you know, money) then bake them some delicious cookies! You can never go wrong with favorites like chocolate chip and sugar cookies. Add cute treat bags like these for the “homemade” look.

23. Mini Notebooks

Mini Notebooks
Check Latest Price

You ever wished you had a piece of scratch paper at hand? You know, like when inspiration for a new poem strikes? Or your wife calls and tells you to pick up a few things at the supermarket and as soon as you hang up you have no idea what those few things were?

Yeah. We know.

Enter in these cute and necessary mini notebooks! Whether you keep them in the car, in your bag, at home by the phone, or whathaveyou, these will fit the bill in a pinch!

24. DIY Hand Painted Ornaments

Check Latest Price

It’s easy to really customize a gift and this is a great way to do it! Bring your creative side to the table and really make these laser cut Christmas trees your own.

With a little paint, maybe some glitter, some personalization, you have an ornament to treasure. This is one Secret Santa gift that they’ll love unwrapping each December as they decorate their tree.

25. What a Beautiful Day Bookmark

What a Beautiful Day - Bookmark
Check Latest Price

A day where you let me read IS a beautiful day! Commemorate the idea and the notion with this sweet and pretty bookmark.

If you have a coworker, favorite aunty, grandfather, friend, child, or spouse, who just loves to bury their head in a book, they will love having a place to mark their spot. Just one more chapter!

Related: How Much Should You Be Spending on Gifts?

Best Secret Santa Gifts for Coworkers

26. Personalized Profession Pacific Crest Sign

Professional Pacific Crest Sign for Librarians
Check Latest Price

A personalized sign is such a great way to show thoughtfulness in your gift giving! This one is just gorgeous with its custom engraving.

It’s made in Oregon, and you don’t have to say “Librarian.” You can customize the wording any way you like. Substitute “Bibliophile,” or “Book Worm,” or whatever other title you prefer. (How about “Book Dragon”?!?! Yes? Yes?!)

Related: Best Gifts for Book Lovers, Bibliophiles & Librarian Types

27. Custom Bobblehead

Custom Bobbleheads
Check Latest Price

Who doesn’t want to be a bobblehead? Um, no one we’ve ever met.

Simply supply a photo of your coworker and in no time you’ll have the perfect gift: a bobblehead of them! They will definitely clap their hands, grin ear to ear, maybe erupt into a fit of belly laughter.

What they won’t do? Look bored, and sigh, “thanks.”

28. Portable Nap Pillow

Gray Portable Nap Pillow
Check Latest Price

Look, I’ve been alive and going to sleep for over 40 years and I STILL don’t know where to put my arms. That’s okay; this portable napping pillow solves all those problems and more!

Such as, how to get in a quick 40 winks during that Zoom meeting, or will anyone notice if I bail on the latest coworker’s birthday cake and instead check my eyelids for light leaks?

29. Gift Card Book

Gift Card Book
Check Latest Price

Sometimes, if you don’t know the person well, it’s really hard to find the perfect gift! That’s okay, because everyone and their brother and their brother’s dog and their brother’s dog’s adopted sister, love gift cards.

This cute Christmas count-down gift card book is like an Advent Calendar for grown-ups!

Related: Best Advent Calendar Filler Ideas

30. Personalized Notepads

Personalized To Do Notepads
Check Latest Price

A great gift for the receptionist or really any coworker, this notepad is totally personalized and is useful for day to day use! No more bland sticky notes or lined yellow paper, no sir.

Would also be great for anyone in your life, not just coworkers. How about your babysitter, piano teacher, school principal, or housekeeper?

Funny Secret Santa Gifts

31. I’m Kinda a Big Dill Mug

Kinda a Big Dill - Funny Mug
Check Latest Price

Because it’s true, that’s why! They are a big dill! This funny and punny mug will make them laugh, and using it at the office is only funnier. Everyone needs a favorite mug: here’s theirs!

32. Flickin’ Chicken

Flickin Chicken Game
Check Latest Price

Sometimes you just have to admit YOU DON’T KNOW WHAT TO BUY THIS PERSON.

That’s okay, because there’s Flickin’ Chicken! It’s all about who can flick their rubber the chicken onto the target. Sounds like Saturday night shenanigans to us!

33. Worlds Hottest Chocolate Bar

Worlds Hottest Chocolate Bar
Check Latest Price

Okay, you could go with a bar of Lindt or Hershey’s, but why would you? Not when there’s the world’s hottest chocolate around! When you need a fun gift for a fun person, look no further than right here.

(Then you can have even more fun watching their face turn red after encouraging them to “just try it already!”)

34. Emergency Alcohol Keyring

Christmas Tipple: Alcohol Keyring
Check Latest Price

Face it. We’ve all needed emergency alcohol at some point. Just like we’ve needed emergency tacos, emergency cake, and emergency midnight Cheetos. But as far as we know, they haven’t invented keychain versions of those last three… sad face.

Anyway, this emergency alcohol keychain is sure to provide some laughs and some much needed… well, you know. Liquid courage. A Christmas tipple, anyone?

35. Slug Night Light

Slug Night Light
Check Latest Price

Why a slug night light? Um, the right questions is actually, why NOT a slug night light? Sleep peacefully as Mr. Slug guards you while you slumber. You can adjust how brightly he glows by pinching his eyes together.

Stop being weird about this. We love Mr. Slug! And don’t worry, he won’t leave a slimy trail behind him.

Read Next: Family Gift Exchange Games for the Holidays

Secret Santa Gifts

Trending Now: