These Handmade Engagement Rings Will Take Your Relationship to Eleven

Handmade engagement rings celebrate the unique love you share in a special way.

As you bend down on one knee to ask for your beloved’s hand, you want to offer a ring that expresses just how much value you place on your unique, intimate, and treasured relationship. You want something that will ensure that your relationship goes to the next step. You want to take it up to eleven.

That’s why you’re not looking at those fancy jewelry shops where everything looks the same. You want something that showcases your sensibilities. Something handmade, something different.

You don’t buy in to the De Beers advertising myth that a ring must be a diamond. (However, if your soon-to-be-betrothed has always dreamed of having one, don’t try to buck the trend!) An engagement ring certainly can have one or more diamonds, but it can also have other gemstones or none at all.

Maybe it will be made from a real piece of meteorite. Perhaps it will feature deer antlers, or whiskey barrel oak wood. Or both. She might adore a one-of-a-kind leafy design, or prefer the natural brilliance of uncut jewels. Maybe you both want something simple and inexpensive, but still beautiful.

Or maybe you don’t know quite what you want, but you’ll know if when you see it. That’s where handmade engagement rings come into play. A handcrafted ring is just different from what you will find at a chain store. If that’s where your search is at, you have come to the right place.

Some of the engagement rings below are affiliate links, which means that – at no cost to you – we may get a small percentage of orders placed after finding the item on our site. That helps keep this blog up and running. See our full disclosure here.

These handmade engagement rings will take your relationship to eleven. They’re the best of the best, and your beloved will know how you searched high and low to find just the right ring. Seek and ye shall find!

Organic Raw Diamond Handmade Engagement Ring

Not only does the raw/unaltered diamond engagement ring have an organic beauty and a trendy BoHo sensibility, it’s also pretty darn affordable. Handmade in Willis, California, from prized Lake County Diamonds.

Twig & Leaf Two Tone 14k Gold with Gemstone

Raw diamonds set into an earthy twig and leaf design, which sets two colors of 14 karat gold in apposition to swirl around the engagement rock.

Marquise Diamond Handmade Engagement Ring

From Capucinne, a renowned jewelry maker in Ljubljana, Slovenia. Marquise diamonds set in a fan-like pave across the top of the piece. Wonder, majesty, and elegance wed in this stunning ring.

Diamond Leaves Engagement Ring

Engagement ring blossoming with pristine beauty. Handmade in Israel using 100% recycled gold, each piece a unique work of art for your beloved.

V Contour Flat Band with Diamond

Graceful elegance for your princess, a true beauty. Individually handcrafted in Chicago, Illinois.

V Contour Diamond Engagement Ring

The lovely princess V shape, with more diamonds. Handmade using recycled gold, perfect for stacking.

Rough Cut Tsavorite Engagement Ring in Recycled 14k Gold

The rough cut of the tsavorite green gemstone gives this piece a sense of rugged authenticity. The natural colors of the greens and golds complement each other. At the same time, the organic rustic look of the holdings create a natural, earthy engagement ring that you will be proud to hold up from one bended knee.

Handmade Gibeon Meteorite Engagement Ring

From the outer reaches of the universe to the promise of your everlasting love, this rose gold engagement ring is handcrafted in Woodbury, Minnesota from the famous Gibeon Meteorite of Namibia.

Deer Antler & Whiskey Barrel Oak Handmade Engagement Ring

Yes, you read that correctly: this stunningly gorgeous engagement ring is handcrafted from a combination of genuine deer antler and oak from whiskey barrels.

Jack Daniels Whiskey Barrel Titanium Ring

This earthy titanium ring is handmade to order in Redding, California. Inlaid with reclaimed whiskey barrel from the famous Jack Daniel’s Tennessee Whiskey company.

Ebony, Sapele, and Argentium Wooden Ring

Argentium silver is set into ebony and sapele brentwood. Argentium is more pure than “traditional” sterling silver (935 vs, 925) and does not tarnish. Handmade in Slovenia.

Etimoe, Cherry, and Turquoise Wooden Ring

A West African tree which is typically tapped for rubber, untapped etimoe produces a beautiful hardwood with similarities to rosewood. Combine it with cherry and a bright splash of turquoise inlay, this is the perfect alternative handmade engagement ring for earthy lovers.

Green Tourmaline Handmade Engagement Ring

Solid 14k rose gold, white gold, or yellow gold band options. Natural conflict-free diamond accents. A centerpiece of green tourmaline in a classic emerald cut. The perfect handmade engagement ring.

Lock of Hair ‘Til Death Do Us Part Engagement Ring

Here’s a unique way to say ‘Til Death Do Us Part. Mourning rings featuring a lock of the loved one’s hair is traditionally a post-death thing. But if you’re planning on being together always, why not get a jump start on it?

Weddings and funeral actually have quite a bit in common. There’s even a wedding-at-a-cemetery trend, and you can see how this theme can be done beautifully and with taste. But before you pop the question with a ring like this, you’d better be pretty darn sure you’re both on the same page!

Celtic Platinum Handmade Engagment Ring

Crafted by hand with Celtic swirls of love holding up a 0.3ct clear center diamond plus two 1.4mm diamonds.

3-Stone Diamond Engagement Ring

Bubinga wood inlays in 14k white gold provide a rustic foundation for the three engagement rocks. The center diamond is 5mm and also GIA certified, with the surrounding stones at 3mm.

Handmade Twisting Split Shank Diamond Engagement Ring

This brilliant-cut ring is in a class of its own. Made with conflict-free diamonds in the weight of your choice. Just look at it! Stunning. She’ll say yes.

Classy Vintage Handmade Engagement Rings

Going vintage is another way to get a one-of-a-kind ring. Many vintage items are handcrafted in the old school style, and you will be hard pressed to find anything like it elsewhere.

Some great vintage engagement ring shops to check out:

More handmade shops:

Handmade Engagement Rings For Under $100

Here are some of our favorite handmade engagement rings that will set you back less than a hundred bucks.

Sometimes you need to play it smart by staying within your means. The proof of your love doesn’t have to be how much cash you can blow on a rock. Rather, sometimes the perfect ring for your engagement is that hard-to-find-hand-crafted-one-of-a-kind quirky, cute, or simple & elegant ring that is handmade just for her.

Summer Dew Wood & Resin Ring

Handcrafted in Russia, these wood rings are carved by hand and topped with jeweler’s resin to create a “secret world” on your beloved’s ring finger. These unique rings have a lifelike feel of nature and otherworldliness.

Handmade Triple Birthstone Ring

These delicate handmade engagement rings feature your choice of three birthstones. A true bargain that is delicate yet ornate. For use as an engagement ring, you could place a diamond in the center with your birthstone to one side and hers to the other.

Art Deco Ring with Diamond Simulants

Brilliant, ornate, handmade, yet still somehow very affordable, this handcrafted engagement ring is sure to thrill her heart.

Elegant Eternity Band

Forged by hand from sterling silver in an enduring “Eternity Twist” design, this handmade engagement ring is simple, pragmatic, and affordable. And yet… and yet, somehow it still looks and feels like it is bursting with everlasting love and passion. It’s just right.

How To Get Her Ring Size

It’s kind of a tradition for the guy to “pop the question” as a surprise. To do so, you need to know the beautiful lady’s ring size in advance. This is especially important when you are considering handmade engagement rings.

There are a few options to secretly and sneakily obtain her ring size, let’s check them out.

1. Buy Now, Resize Later

This is a bit lame, but it works. Just get a ring that’s close to her size, and then take it in afterwards to fit it correctly. The bummer about this is that, if the ring is too small, she won’t be able to put it on after saying “yes.” Or, if the ring is too big, it will flop around loosely. On the suave scale of Pee Wee Herman to James Dean, this option is about a Ron Weasley.

2. Take a Ring to the Jeweler

Find a ring that you know she wears, just not all the time. Take it in to a jeweler and bam, you’re don.

3. Call Mom

If you’ve done the gallant thing and asked her parents for her hand, this should be a piece of cake. Sometimes mom already knows, other times she can find a way to sneak a ring. Other options aside from her mother include sisters, roomates, BFFs, and co-workers.

4. Trace

Grab her favorite ring when she takes it off for a moment, and trace the inside. Take this in to a jeweler and they should be able to get the size.

5. Talk About It

I personally don’t recommend this one. She’ll pick up on it way to fast. But, if you’re the daring type, give it a go. Try to casually steer the topic towards ring and finger sizes. Buy her a cheap gift ring from a street vendor at a Saturday Market, and pay attention to the size. Say you’re looking for a gift for your sister or mom, and that you think she has a similar ring size. But don’t be surprised if she sees right through these!

And last, the ring box

With such a beautiful engagement ring, you’ll want to store it somewhere special. Here’s the thing for you:

The ring bearer can carry the rings on a pillow, if you wanted to go the traditional route. But you probably don’t. So have the ring bearer bring in this gorgeous wooden ring box, custom engraved just for the wedding.

Read Next: Traditional Engagement Gifts

Best Handmade Engagement Rings
Photo of author

Daniel Szczesniak

Daniel launched All Gifts Considered in 2013 to help people find the best gift ideas for anyone and any occasion. He has worked for Northwest Gifts, an online gift shop based in Oregon specializing in American-made and personalized gifts, for...

... read more

Leave a Comment